Strategies

The Individual Edition CD

This month I released my 8th full-length album, slated to be my last physical release. I might have gone the digital-only route this time if I hadn’t won free CD manufacturing from Disc Makers through the John Lennon Songwriting Contest. The fact that it was a physical release allowed me to take pre-orders, which provided the opportunity to test out my latest crazy idea – one that actually panned out for a change! Here is how I described The Individual Edition CD to my fans:

It will probably come as a surprise that I can’t create the exact same mix twice, even though the album was recorded entirely “in the box” on my studio computer. Arpeggiators randomly cycle through the notes of a chord. Panning effects start and end at different points. Some devices purposely insert glitches and other random anomalies. Beyond the occasional surprise, these differences are tough to pick out unless you know what to listen for. The qualitative listening experience is the same, but the fact that each mixdown is an “audio snowflake” gave me an idea:

As a souvenir of your support, I will create a personalized custom CD featuring unique mixdowns of each of the 12 songs I recorded for the album. The outtakes “Touch” and “Release the Hounds” are not on the standard Limited Edition CD and will not appear on any future physical release. The disc will open with a token of my appreciation – a spoken “thank you” mentioning you by name.

The Individual Edition CD is available through July 31. Keeping in mind that it takes me three hours to prepare each one, I’ve priced it at $99, which also includes a copy of the standard Limited Edition version. I don’t have much spare time to devote to this, so I can only take the first 20 orders. They will ship as soon as the CDs arrive, most likely before the August 4 release date.

If you can think of anything I can do to make it more special or meaningful, please let me know!

I ran it by a few friends first, and the consensus was that it was a cool idea, but pricy. I argued that $99 was reasonable considering how much time it takes to put one together. If nobody ordered, it would’ve been pathetic, but I wouldn’t have had to lift a finger. If I got more orders than I could handle, I would’ve had to turn people away.

Fortunately, the price was on target. I got 13 orders, generating more than 50% of the approximately $2,500 I’ve made in sales since I launched the album. The recipients seem to love the CDs, and I genuinely enjoyed putting them together.

The Individual Edition CD

I realize that as the artist, mix engineer, and mastering engineer of the album, I’m in a unique position to pull this off. Beyond that, the mixes required a degree of randomness that might not make sense in a non-electronic context. No matter what your role or style of music, there are variations on the theme that would excite and entice your fans:

  1. Deleted scenes. Remember that guitar solo you cut because it seemed too “self-indulgent”? That redundant 3rd verse? That 45 second fade-out? Your fans might enjoy hearing them in an extended arrangement, if only to compare and contrast with the album version.
  2. Live show for one. How about a personalized one-off live recording of the album? Make sure to mention the guest of honor by name and leave in the mistakes! If playing through the whole album is too much work, how about dedicating a single song of their choice from your discography?
  3. Unique vocal. You could use alternate vocal takes, or even change a line of the lyrics to include a fan’s name. How about inserting a clever line about how you’ve “done this 12 times already” and increment the number with each take? Even if you’ve already finished tracking the band, overdubbing a vocal is relatively quick and painless.
  4. Fan sing-a-long. Anyone with an iPhone can record themselves singing along to the chorus of your song. It wouldn’t be too hard to tune it and layer it with the lead vocal. Who wouldn’t want to share the results with everybody on their friends list? Alternately, you could layer takes from any fan who wants to contribute and sell the same “fan sing-a-long” version to everyone. It could even work in a live setting by recording the audience singing along, then handing out download cards telling them where to get the recording.

All of the above options require some mixing work and a mastering engineer to run the songs through the gear again for cheap. The cost might be hard to justify if you’re paying by the hour. If nothing else, you can always insert a vocal greeting or song introduction as an extra track on the disc. If you’ve got a mic and a computer with a CD burner, there’s nothing stopping you from making your release extra special for your most dedicated fans.

You Might Also Like

3 Comments

  • Reply
    Kara
    August 17, 2010 at 12:37 pm

    Brian- Awesome post. This really excites me. We’ll be releasing our second album soon and I’ve been trying to come up with something extra for our most supportive fans. I’ll probably go the video route… perhaps play an acoustic version (we’re an electro anti-folk duo) of an album song of their choice and dedicate it to them… Oooo- for that matter, we could offer an acoustic version of the entire album. Thanks for the inspiration- big time!

  • Reply
    Monty Singleton
    August 18, 2010 at 9:48 am

    Great article!

    Part of me is greatly saddened to see the death of the old music industry because there is so much I loved about it. However, it’s very exciting to see how things are evolving and the latest movement of “Crowdfunding.” Brian, this Podcast from CD Baby was just posted two days ago and is very much in-sync with what you did with the “Individual Edition.”

    Brian Meece – The Crowdfunding Manifesto

    http://cdbabypodcast.com/?p=915

  • Reply
    Brian Hazard
    August 18, 2010 at 3:00 pm

    I like that Kara! A video dedication of a song of their choice seems like it would be much more intimate than just a voiceover on the CD.

    Monty, I’ll have to check that out! I’ve outright fan funding attempts because *to me* it comes off as begging. While other sites take a more investment-oriented approach, I wouldn’t want to take advantage of the artist-fan relationship by promising vast riches.

  • Share Your Thoughts